13 Sandwiches That Turn Skeptics Into Fans
Some sandwiches sound odd until you try them. Others just quietly win you over one bite at a time. These thirteen creations have a track record of turning doubters into believers. Whether it’s a regional quirk or a classic done differently, every one of them earns respect fast.
Chow Mein Sandwich
At first glance, noodles on a bun sound like a dare. But Fall River’s Chow Mein Sandwich turns that weirdness into genius; crunchy, saucy, and impossible to put down. Get the recipe here.
Olive Burger
Michigan’s olive-topped creation gets side-eyes from the uninitiated. But once that salty, tangy spread hits the juicy burger, everyone’s a convert. Get the recipe here.
Liverwurst Sandwich
It’s old-school and proudly so. Smooth, rich, and full-bodied, this sandwich wins skeptics with its throwback simplicity and perfect spread-to-bread balance. Get the recipe here.
Cudighi Sandwich
This spicy-sweet sausage from Michigan’s Upper Peninsula doesn’t need convincing once it’s on your plate. Marinara and melted cheese seal the deal for skeptics everywhere. Get the recipe here.
Fried Bologna Sandwich
It’s not fancy; it’s better. A slice of fried bologna, mayo, and white bread reminds people why nostalgia tastes good. Simple, salty perfection. Get the recipe here.
Runza
Nebraska’s stuffed bread pocket doesn’t look flashy, but that first bite of warm beef and cabbage changes minds immediately. It’s the comfort you didn’t know you missed. Get the recipe here.
Pueblo Slopper
A burger smothered in green chile might sound like chaos, but Pueblo, Colorado made it an art form. Messy, spicy, and downright addictive. Get the recipe here.
North Shore Beef
Massachusetts’ regional treasure doesn’t need to explain itself. Rare roast beef, BBQ sauce, and cheese win over even the most skeptical outsiders. Get the recipe here.
Benedictine Sandwich
Kentucky’s cucumber spread sandwich is light, cool, and way better than it sounds. One bite, and doubters realize simplicity can still hit hard. Get the recipe here.
Horseshoe Sandwich
Fries, cheese sauce, and toast shouldn’t make sense as a sandwich; but Illinois proves it absolutely does. This dish wins over skeptics through sheer excess. Get the recipe here.
Polish Boy
Cleveland’s fries-on-a-sausage sandwich sounds like a dare until you eat it. The BBQ sauce, slaw, and chaos work together flawlessly. Get the recipe here.
Hot Beef Sandwich
It looks like a fork-and-knife project, and it is; but that gravy-soaked combo of beef, bread, and mashed potatoes wins everyone over. Midwest comfort at full strength. Get the recipe here.
Fish Fry Sandwich
Even skeptics of seafood fold after Wisconsin’s Friday fish fry. Crispy fish, soft bun, and a cold drink; it’s a ritual worth believing in. Get the recipe here.