9 Sandwich Combos That Should Not Work But Absolutely Do
Fluffernutter Sandwich
Massachusetts gave us the Fluffernutter Sandwich, a sticky, sweet mash-up of peanut butter and marshmallow cream that defies logic and nutrition alike. Somehow, it still wins every time.
Chow Mein Sandwich
The Chow Mein Sandwich from Fall River, Massachusetts, shouldn’t exist—but thank goodness it does. Crispy noodles in brown gravy stuffed into a bun turn chaos into comfort.
Muffuletta Sandwich
New Orleans’ Muffuletta looks like a dare on paper: olive salad, salami, mortadella, and provolone jammed into a round loaf. Yet one bite proves the chaos makes perfect sense.
Runza
Nebraska’s Runza hides ground beef, cabbage, and onions inside bread dough. It’s half sandwich, half secret casserole, and somehow completely addictive.
Polish Boy
Cleveland’s Polish Boy piles fries, coleslaw, and BBQ sauce over a sausage. It’s a glorious mess that tastes like every cookout smashed into one bite.
Cudighi Sandwich
The Cudighi Sandwich from Michigan’s Upper Peninsula turns spiced Italian sausage into a Midwest marvel. Cinnamon and nutmeg shouldn’t work in sausage—but they do.
Hot Brown Sandwich
Louisville’s Hot Brown is what happens when turkey, Mornay sauce, and bacon crash into a broiler. Creamy, rich, and borderline absurd in concept, yet it nails the landing.
Navajo Taco
The Navajo Taco swaps sandwich bread for frybread and throws in beans, beef, and cheese. It’s a full dinner disguised as a handheld experiment that works too well.
Tomato Sandwich
The Tomato Sandwich is proof that mayo and fresh summer tomatoes don’t need backup singers. Simple, messy, and perfect against all odds.