14 Indulgent Sandwiches Americans Love the Most

If you’re after sandwiches that don’t hold back, these picks deliver the goods. Each one is unapologetically rich, piled high, and guaranteed to make you rethink what “indulgence” really means.

Tuna Melt

Toasty bread, melty cheese, and creamy tuna salad team up for a classic that’s always indulgent. This is comfort food with a crispy, golden edge. Get the Tuna Melt recipe

Pit Beef

Pit beef is Baltimore’s answer to barbecue, stacked with smoky sliced beef, raw onion, and a strong hit of horseradish. If you like a sandwich with bold attitude, this one is legendary. Get the Pit Beef recipe

Horseshoe Sandwich

Springfield, Illinois takes indulgence to a whole new level with the Horseshoe: Texas toast, burger patties, fries, and a generous slather of cheese sauce. It’s a glorious mess on a plate. Get the Horseshoe Sandwich recipe

Detroit Coney Dog

A beefy hot dog blanketed in beanless chili, onions, and mustard is Detroit’s ultimate comfort food. One bite and you’ll get why this is an American icon. Get the Detroit Coney Dog recipe

Chicago Dog

What do you get when you combine an all-beef dog with a salad bar’s worth of toppings? The iconic Chicago Dog, famous for its snap and its serious toppings game. Get the Chicago Dog recipe

Seattle Dog

This hot dog comes with grilled onions and a thick smear of cream cheese, which sounds wild until you try it. Seattle’s late-night staple is comfort in a bun. Get the Seattle Dog recipe

Chicken Spiedie

Juicy marinated chicken, grilled and packed into a sub roll, delivers big flavor and plenty of personality. The spiedie’s magic is in its marinade; a Binghamton original. Get the Chicken Spiedie recipe

North Shore Beef

Roast beef, barbecue sauce, cheese, and mayo all stuffed into an onion roll. This Massachusetts legend is so stacked, you might need a nap afterward. Get the North Shore Beef recipe

Loose Meat Sandwich

Seasoned ground beef crumbles piled high on a soft bun. Iowa’s loose meat sandwich keeps it simple but delivers unbeatable comfort. Get the Loose Meat Sandwich recipe

Vermonter Sandwich

Layers of turkey, sharp cheddar, apple slices, and maple mustard come together for a sandwich that screams Vermont. Hearty, sweet, and rich; this one’s a fall day in sandwich form. Get the Vermonter Sandwich recipe

Roast Pork Sandwich

Packed with garlicky pork, sharp provolone, and sautéed greens, Philadelphia’s roast pork is juicy, rich, and built for serious appetites. Get the Roast Pork Sandwich recipe

Sonoran Hot Dog

This bacon-wrapped Tucson dog is loaded with beans, salsas, and a parade of toppings. It’s messy, colorful, and pure indulgence. Get the Sonoran Hot Dog recipe

Grinder Sandwich

Heaps of Italian meats, cheese, and all the works. The Connecticut grinder is the definition of an overstuffed hero, guaranteed to satisfy. Get the Grinder Sandwich recipe